April 9: Two Historic Surrenders

In American history, April 9 is a standout date because of two historic surrenders.

On April 9, 1865, Confederate General Robert E. Lee surrendered about 28,000 of his troops at Appomattox Court House, Virginia, to General Ulysses S. Grant. The Union general offered paroles (pardons) to the Southern officers and soldiers, allowed the officers to retained their sidearms and their horses, distributed rations, and sent the defeated men home. The Civil War had all but ended. The Union was restored; slavery was finished.

On April 9, 1942, General Edward P. King surrendered about 75,000 American and Filipino troops to the Japanese following a protracted, bitter fight on the Bataan peninsula on the Philippine island of Luzon. King received assurances that his sick and wounded men would be well treated.

The war in the Pacific was nowhere near an end. Some American and Filipino troops still held out against the Japanese on the fortified island of Corregidor. They didn’t last long, surrendering less than a month after Bataan.

In the meantime, the good treatment promised to the American and Filipino prisoners on Bataan never materialized. The Japanese hadn’t expected such a large number of POWs and weren’t prepared or inclined to deal with them. To relocate tens of thousands of malnourished, battle weary men to a hastily constructed prison camp, the Japanese ordered them to start walking.

Sanchez was among 1,800 New Mexican soldiers who were forced to take part in the death march, which started near Marivales in the Philippines in 1942 after U.S. forces on Bataan surrendered. (The Associated Press File Photo)

Over about sixty-five miles, thousands perished on what would later be called the Bataan Death March. Those who survived faced a new hell: either Camp O’Donnell or Cabanatuan, or both. Later, most of the survivors would be shipped off for forced labor in Japan or other places in Asia.

In and around Manila, four American women closely followed the fortunes of these men. Risking their lives, they chose to participate in the underground to provide as much assistance as they could to the prisoners.

For more about the Bataan surrender and about the four women, read Angels of the Underground.

Celebrating Easter Under an Enemy Occupation

After Japanese forces occupied the Philippines in early 1942, American civilians and other Allied nationals were forced into internment camps. The camps had a plethora of rules, including a ban on “commingling”–an enforced separation between adult men and women, including husbands and wives–and rules on what women could and could not wear.

Camp commandants demanded that women be “decently” attired at all times with discreet necklines and long skirts, just like proper Japanese women. But because of the almost unrelenting heat of the Philippines, American women tried to get away with as few articles of clothing as possible while remaining seemly by their own standards.

In the Santo Tomas internment camp in Manila, women were particularly forbidden to wear shorts of any length. The camp’s civilian Executive Committee, run by men of the Allied countries, approved of the ban no matter how much the women resisted, believing they were saving their women from the possibility of sexual assault by the Japanese. However, by the end of 1943, clothing was in such short supply that the Japanese agreed to relax the ban. Women could wear shorts that were no more than four inches above the knee.

To take control of their appearance and to reassert American traditions, the women in the Baguio internment camp celebrated Easter of 1942 by attending a sunrise service with their families, then staging a parade during the Sunday night socializing hour.

Almost every adult woman created a new Easter hat, long an American tradition, and joined the parade. Missionary Fern Harrington recalled that “shrieks of hilarity punctuated the afternoon as the women fashioned their hats.” She covered a strawberry basket with a variety of flowers she had picked the day before. Harrington declared that the “smartest” hat was the one made from a roll of toilet paper tied to a woman’s head with a ribbon. Another woman wore a branch on her head adorned with a paper bird. Yet another hung onions from her ears as earrings and arranged long green sprouts on her head.

The parade was a big success. The internees laughed as they thoroughly enjoyed themselves, that is, until the Japanese guards heard the commotion and moved in to break up the event. It had been one of a few bright spots in what would stretch into three years of life under an enemy occupation.

Want to know more about American women’s experiences under internment? Read Prisoners in Paradise: American Women in the Wartime South Pacific.

 

Historical Thoughts on Valentine’s Day

Today is a big day for hearts and flowers, boxes of chocolates and candlelight dinners.

On Valentine’s Day of 1942, Peggy Utinsky was holed up in her apartment in Manila, hiding from Japanese occupation authorities. They were rounding up American nationals to put them in civilian internment camps. Peggy was determined not to go. She would feel useless there, and she wouldn’t be able to find out what happened to her husband, Jack.

Peggy kept a low profile, arranged for false identity papers, and joined a Philippine Red Cross medical expedition to the Bataan peninsula later that spring. Maybe there she could find Jack.

Read the rest of the story in Angels of the Underground.